INT31-C Ensure that integer conversions do not result in lost or misinterpreted data SEI CERT C Coding Standard Confluence


C11 and C++11 both have nothing like this around the usual arithmetic conversion rules… The rank of any enumerated type shall equal the rank of the compatible integer type. The questioner’s machine is two’s complement as evidenced by the values he reported. Endianess has nothing to do with it; I am only using int valves here, not individual bytes from memory.

unsigned int to int

Well, because there IS possibility of wraparound; it’s just not mandated by the standard. On many platforms, including x86, signed ints do wrap. But the standard leaves this as undefined behavior, allowing other platforms to treat signed int overflow differently.

If you could specifically cite some examples and update your question for the part “…by an lvalue that has one of the following types…” where the stars proceed the samples above it would be very helpful. Because we are casting the address of x to the signed version of it’s type, that’s permitted by the C standard. It seems like you are expecting int and unsigned int to be a 16-bit integer. Most likely, it’s a 32-bit integer – which is large enough to avoid the wrap-around that you’re expecting. But then ISO C violates the rule quite often, in having time() return ( -1). There is no standard way to reference the maximum time_t value except by saying ( -1).

Convert from Signed to Std_Logic_Vector using Numeric_Std

This way of representing numbers allows addition, subtraction and multiplication to be carried out by the computer in the same way regardless of whether the numbers are signed or unsigned. If the incorrect calculations above are repeated with two’s complement we’ll How to Create a SharePoint Online Project Site: Step-By-Step see that it will now give us the correct results. Assignment inherently includes conversion in C for types where the assignment makes sense (and even for some where it doesn’t). But this will cause problems if the unsigned value is past the max int can hold.

Yeah, thanks I was a bit unsure on the casting to short part. The multiply shifts left 16 bits , and the divide shifts right maintaining the sign. To understand why, you need to know that the CPU represents signed numbers using the two’s complement . I have added the exception I suggested earlier, and tweaked the code examples wrt the exception for clarity. I’ve fixed the wording to be more accurate; it was a size_t that was being given a 64-bit value, which overflows on platforms where a size_t is treated as a 32-bit value.

This means half of the possible unsigned values will result in erroneous behaviour unless you specifically watch out for it. Unsigned keyword followed by nested long type integer. In this article, we will discuss the maximum value of unsigned int in C++. The signed variable is a bit too small, but you want to avoid the memory and speed loss of long/float. The calculation is done in the scope of the destination variable. E.g. if the destination variable is signed, it will do signed math, even if both input variables are unsigned.

  • I’ve fixed the wording to be more accurate; it was a size_t that was being given a 64-bit value, which overflows on platforms where a size_t is treated as a 32-bit value.
  • The representation of the values 65529u and -7 are identical for 16-bit ints.
  • Also, because uc is equal to UCHAR_MAX, which is equal to UINT_MAX, the addition results in an overflow in this example.
  • A naive way to handle the negative values is to note if the sign bit is 1, which means that the value is negative, and then interpret the rest of the bits as before.

It’s still worthwhile IMHO as the conversion is not obvious to most programmers. Search for vulnerabilities resulting from the violation of this rule on the CERT website. //If any dynamic memory https://forexaggregator.com/ allocation functions fail within this function, return NULL, but be careful to avoid memory leaks when you do so. I’m debugging my code and this seems to be the problem, but I’m not sure.

Convert from Unsigned to Std_Logic_Vector using Numeric_Std

C++ unsigned int is the best option whenever the requirement is to use positive integers as it is compatible with networking and systems to deal with optimization with respect to memory for networking and systems. Compare this to the 1-byte signed integer range of -128 to 127. Both can store 256 different values, but signed integers use half of their range for negative numbers, whereas unsigned integers can store positive numbers that are twice as large. Otherwise, both operands are converted to the unsigned integer type corresponding to the type of the operand with signed integer type. The time() function returns the value (-1) to indicate that the calendar time is not available.

Although conversions are generally required for the correct execution of a program, they can also lead to lost or misinterpreted data. Conversion of an operand value to a compatible type causes no change to the value or the representation. Therefore, conversion of a negative compile-time constant to an unsigned value with the same or larger width is permitted by this rule. This exception does not apply to conversion of unsigned to signed values, nor does it apply if the resulting value would undergo truncation.

However, it’s possible for this to screw up on a one’s complement machine, but those are so, so rare, and so, so obsolete, I wouldn’t even bother with looking out for them. Typically, converting an integer to a smaller type results in truncation of the high-order bits. // Convert the unsigned integer n to HugeInteger format. But since we are limited to 4 bits the extra digit is simply lost. The result is correct except for the sign that is incorrect. To handle this we could add a new rule that says that the sign bit should be 1 if both values are negative, but we will see that it becomes more complicated when the two numbers have different sign.

In this compliant solution, the bitwise complement of port is converted back to 8 bits. Consequently, result_8 is assigned the expected value of 0x0aU. The real question is what you want to do when/if the value in the unsigned int it out of the range that can be represented by a signed int. If it’s out of range, that’ll give an unspecified result so you’ll probably want to reduce it the right range first, or assign it to a larger signed type. Wherever there is a need to develop embedded systems comprising of processors or memory limited activity there only a need for C++ unsigned integer. Unsigned int data type in C++ is used to store 32-bit integers.

Oddly, the C++ standard explicitly says “a computation involving unsigned operands can never overflow”. This is contrary to general programming consensus that integer overflow encompasses both signed and unsigned use cases . Given that most programmers would consider this overflow, we’ll call this overflow despite C++’s statements to the contrary.

The rank of any standard integer type shall be greater than the rank of any extended integer type with the same width. The rank of long long int shall be greater than the rank of long int, which shall be greater than the rank of int, which shall be greater than the rank of short int, which shall be greater than the rank of signed char. It’s all about how signed numbers are stored in memory. Do a search for twos-complement notation for more detail, but here are the basics. That is, each code example (compliant or non-) should be discernible from the rule’s title, intro text, and exceptions. Whatever the developer intended should be irrelevant; the code is all that matters.

Not the answer you’re looking for? Browse other questions tagged cpointersintunsigned or ask your own question.

Note that many of the below examples use the ‘length VHDL attribute. This attribute makes your code more portable and versatile, so it should be used. In the PC game Civilization, Gandhi was known for often being the first one to use nuclear weapons, which seems contrary to his expected passive nature. Players had a theory that Gandhi’s aggression setting was initially set at 1, but if he chose a democratic government, he’d get a -2 aggression modifier . This would cause his aggression to overflow to 255, making him maximally aggressive! However, more recently Sid Meier (the game’s author) clarified that this wasn’t actually the case.

The rank of any unsigned integer type shall equal the rank of the corresponding signed integer type, if any. Conversions to unsigned character types are well defined by C to have modular behavior. A character’s value is not misinterpreted by the loss of sign or conversion to a negative number. For example, the Euro symbol € is sometimes represented by bit pattern 0x80 which can have the numerical value 128 or −127 depending on the signedness of the type.

unsigned int to int

The below example uses the conv_std_logic_vector conversion, which requires two input parameters. The below example uses the conv_signed conversion, which requires two input parameters. The below example uses the to_signed conversion, which requires two input parameters.

Compliant Solution (Unsigned, Loss of Precision)

The promotion will be to signed int, which then overflows and results in Undefined Behavior. This can come as a big surprise, since all of the variables’ types are unsigned. IIUC the -1 is converted to an unsigned integer by adding UINT_MAX+1.

Assuming that the precision of signed char is 7 bits, and the precision of unsigned char is 8 bits, this operation is perfectly safe. However, if the compiler represents the signed char and unsigned char types using 31- and 32-bit precision , the variable uc would need to be converted to unsigned int instead of signed int. As a result of the usual arithmetic conversions, the signed int is converted to unsigned, and the addition takes place between the two unsigned int values. Also, because uc is equal to UCHAR_MAX, which is equal to UINT_MAX, the addition results in an overflow in this example.

Whole numbers are stored in computers as a series of bits of fixed length. They can either be interpreted as an unsigned value which means that no negative values are allowed, or they can be interpreted as a signed value which allows both positive and negative values. The maximum value that can be stored is about twice as big with unsigned compared to with signed. Therefore, there are certain interesting fields where the user should use C++ unsigned integers without giving a second thought and that is whenever the user wants to deal with manipulation in bits. Many notable bugs in video game history happened due to wrap around behavior with unsigned integers.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *